Once again we have a gospel reading that skips over an important piece of scripture. In Chapter 14 we see the transition from old to new. We see the kingdom of heaven Jesus has been preaching on come to fulfillment with the presence of God's abundance and the feeding of the 5000. And we see the boat in the storm as a metaphor for the new community needing Christ in its midst.
Now, in Chapter 15, we begin to see this new community evolve in a variety of ways. But as I said, the lectionary skips over some critical information. After the incident in the boat, Jesus and the disciples end up in Gennesaret where he is recognized and people bring all those who were sick to be healed. Eventually some Pharisees and scribes arrive accusing his group of breaking tradition by not washing their hands before eating. This wasn't your mother's hand washing, or the hand washing we all did during COVID, but a symbolic hand washing to remove the stain of touching unclean things. Jesus responds by saying, “And why do you break the commandment of God for the sake of tradition?” then lays into them for their hypocrisy. And here is where we enter the story.
The first half of today's gospel has Jesus addressing the crowds in response to his confrontation with the Pharisees. In this new community Jesus is trying to establish, he uses the Pharisees and scribes as an example of how not to behave.
The Pharisees had advertised standards that they expected everyone to live by and were quick to call out anyone who didn't live up to those expectations. But they also managed to absolve themselves of any wrongdoing through this same tactic. It followed the pattern of seeing someone who offends your interpretation and then attack them vigorously and loudly, and accuse them of the very things you allow for yourself. Jesus responds to them by saying, “You want to know what defiles a person? It's what comes out of your mouth: evil intentions, murder, slander, theft, false witness.”
As this new community of Christ begins to take shape, Jesus is trying to establish some rules of behavior. What Jesus addressed then is just as valid today. Social media is a good place to start. It doesn't take much looking to find accounts who identify themselves as “Follower of Jesus,” or with tag lines of, “Love God, Be Kind,” “Celebrate life,” “Becoming the person I should be,” and other such wholesome bios with overly religious or kind sayings about respecting people, only to find they make comments on other pages about body-shaming, how terrible they look, or slapping them for having opinions. This happens in politics as well where people will state the most outlandish claims and lies in order to scare people or drive them into a sense of panic. Never mind that the truth is nowhere to be found – if you repeat the lie often enough, people will believe it.
I'm glad I'm not a kid these days, or have a young kid these days. We all know kids can be cruel, but in this age of cyberbullying it's been taken to an extreme. How many cases of suicide have there been because a child was driven to the breaking point and decided the only option was to die?
Claiming to be on the moral high ground while making personal attacks against those whom we don't like, find annoying, or don't meet our definition of “normal” puts us in the same group as the Pharisees whom Jesus was attacking for doing the very same thing.
And as if to drive this point home, this teaching about what comes out of the mouth proceeding from the heart and defiling us is followed by the encounter with the Canaanite woman.
The first thing to understand about this story is that Israelites and Canaanites were generational enemies. That hatred goes all the way back to Genesis 9 when Noah cursed Ham and his descendants, the Canaanites, after the flood. So this person who approached Jesus was 1) a foreigner, 2) a woman, 3) probably a single woman, and 4) a sworn enemy. Yet here she is begging Jesus for mercy.
Not only is she begging for mercy, but she recognizes who he is by calling him Lord and Son of David. But even when she uses this title, Jesus ignores her. This is reminiscent of Ps. 22:2 when the psalmist wrote, “O My God, I cry by day, but you do not answer.” Neither Jesus nor the disciples have time for this annoyance, so they do what they can to make her leave.
Yet she is persistent, coming to kneel before him. This humble act recalls others in this gospel who have knelt before him and acknowledged him as Lord and/or Savior – the magi, a leper, a synagogue leader, and the disciples in the boat last week.
In this exchange between Jesus and the woman we see a very uncomfortable image of Jesus. Here all of his humanity comes through – the biases against foreigners and women, and the desire to focus on me and my own first.
In one respect, Jesus is not wrong. The Son of God comes to the lost sheep of Israel. He has come to restore the relationship between God and his people. He is the person who is both the culmination of Israel's history and the point of contact for God in the world. With that in mind, Jesus rightly says, “I'm not for you.”
But humans can learn, and God can change God's mind. The Flood was a bad idea that God never repeated. God opted to not destroy Nineveh. And Jesus, prodded by this woman's plea, may have heard his own words from just a bit ago: “It isn't what goes into the mouth that defiles, but it is what comes out of the mouth from the heart that defiles.” O snap.
It's an odd feeling when a preacher realizes the words spoken are directed at themselves. This very well could have been Jesus' “Aha” moment. The moment when he realized his mission wasn't limited to Israel but was open to all who chose to follow him. As such, this is also the moment his disciples and the early Church recognize the same thing. This is also the natural progression of the new community Jesus is trying to establish.
In Chapter 13 we were given kingdom parables telling us the kingdom of heaven was very near and showing us what to look for. Chapter 14 showed us what the kingdom of heaven/new community of Christ could look like if we all cared for others as God cares with the feeding of the 5000. We saw the peace of Christ being with us in the boat. Today we saw how the community of Christ should behave to avoid defilement in our words and actions. And we see how this new community of Christ is to take in and welcome people we initially want no part of.
Both of today's passages – the issue of hand washing and the issue of the Canaanite woman – remind us that we cannot be contaminated or made less-than by outside circumstances, forces, genders, sexuality, nationalities, or any other difference we perceive. Both of these passages remind us that what defiles us, what contaminates us, what takes us away from the kingdom of heaven is how we speak about and treat others. We must always remember that we are reflective of the new community of Christ and the kingdom of heaven here on earth: a community that is present and attainable now, a community that lives in abundance, a community with Jesus at its center, a community with a morality of love, and a community that welcomes all who proclaim Christ above all.
Amen.