I read this article from Get Religion earlier this morning. In short, it's about a Thanksgiving Day service in Austin, TX, that was forced to change venues because the Baptist church that was to host it objected to "non-Christians worshiping on its property."
Now, on the surface, that's an okay statement. It also might be called a correct statement. I would not open my parish to a Muslim, Jewish, Wiccan or whatever service; nor would I allow a non-Christian family to hold a funeral or wedding in my parish because "it's pretty."
However, there are a few other things to consider (some of which the article points out, some which it doesn't):
1) Last time I looked, Thanksgiving wasn't a religious holiday. It was a day to give thanks (okay, to God .... but that makes sense since the colonists were Christian) for the hospitality of the Native Americans so that the colonists wouldn't starve and, thereby, continue their world domination of other cultures.
2) From the G.R. article: The rental space in question is a gymnasium, not a sanctuary. This doesn't make sense to me. We loan out our parish hall out to all sorts of non-Christian groups. And the last time I looked, the parish hall (and I have to believe their gymnasium) wasn't set aside and consecrated as a holy space. And if the gym was, maybe they should take a look at what goes on in that gym during basketball games, because I gotta believe that there is some less-than-Christian behavior going on in the heat of competition.
3) Also from the G.R. article: The statement from the church says that it welcomes “all faiths” to worship, but won’t allow its property to be used for “non-Christian religions.” And this one REALLY doesn't make sense to me. How can you "welcome all faiths to worship," while at the same time not allow your property to be used for "non-Christian religions"? Isn't that a little like saying, "We welcome all people to worship -- except sinners." That just makes no sense at all, and how someone can make that judgment is almost beyond . . .
Oh . . . wait . . .
Ft. Worth, Quincy, San Joaquin, Southern Cone, Nigeria . . .
Wednesday, November 21, 2007
Coexistence
Posted by
Reverend Ref +
at
9:31 AM
Labels: church
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
A Few Words About Comments
Comments are always welcome here, but there are a few things you should know:
1) If you comment, leave a name. If you can't figure out how to log in or register or whatever the system is making you do (which, believe me, I fully understand how frustrating that can be) and you must comment anonymously . . . leave a name in the comment section. Purely anonymous comments will be deleted.
2) Comments I deem to be offensive, irrelevant, or generally trollish will be deleted. I'm mainly talking to the Akurians here. Don't make me get out my flag!
3) If you would like to receive e-mail notification of other comments so you can more easily follow a conversation (yeah, like I ever have those on this blog), you must register with Blogger. Sorry . . . I didn't have anything to do with that one.
Enjoy the game.
1) If you comment, leave a name. If you can't figure out how to log in or register or whatever the system is making you do (which, believe me, I fully understand how frustrating that can be) and you must comment anonymously . . . leave a name in the comment section. Purely anonymous comments will be deleted.
2) Comments I deem to be offensive, irrelevant, or generally trollish will be deleted. I'm mainly talking to the Akurians here. Don't make me get out my flag!
3) If you would like to receive e-mail notification of other comments so you can more easily follow a conversation (yeah, like I ever have those on this blog), you must register with Blogger. Sorry . . . I didn't have anything to do with that one.
Enjoy the game.
The War in Ukraine
Friends' Parishes
Clergy Blogs
Friendly Blogs
Mental Recess
- Awesome Food Recipes
- Awkward Family Photos
- Babylon Bee
- Bloggess
- Brick Testament
- Cake Wrecks
- Catholic Satire
- Chocoloate
- G.U. "Zags" Men's Basketball
- G.U. "Zags" Women's Basketball
- Motivational Reality
- NASA
- Optical Illusions
- Politics, Religion, Sports, and Stuff
- Red Green
- Right Behind
- Secular Religion
- Veggie Tales!
- WHL Hockey
Personal Stuff
small god in an itty-bitty box that i made in wood shop
Previous Posts
The Church
Church News Sites
Church Resources
- Anglican Liturgy in New Zealand
- Backstory Preaching
- BCPs of the Anglican Communion
- Bible Gateway
- Build Faith Bible Studies
- Canadian Confirmation
- Christian Classics Etheral Library
- Crosswalk Bible Concordance
- Daily Office Prayer
- Daily Offices
- Forward Movement
- Grow Christians
- Lectionary for the Church Year
- Lectionary Musings
- Olive Tree Bible Search
- Order of the Ascension
- Orthodox History
- Pop Theology
- The Anglican Theological Review
- The Hymnal 1982
- The Thoughtful Christian
- Time Management
- Working Preacher
Politics
Religion
Archive
2 comments:
How can you "welcome all faiths to worship," while at the same time not allow your property to be used for "non-Christian religions"?
Simple: A Muslim can come and join us for worship any Sunday morning, but that same Muslim cannot hold his/her own services in the space. Everyone's welcome to come to Christian worship in their space.
Fr Mark has solved that one.
"We welcome all people to worship -- except sinners."
Which is not what the conservative dioceses are saying.
Both sides welcome sinners.
The row is about whether certain acts are sins or not. The conservatives say something like my line, 'All are welcome to come and pray in a Catholic church', and we all are sinners; the other side is saying 'we're not sinning by doing and approving the same-sex thing'.
Post a Comment